In the penal colony essay

How is it justified for a group of people, like the officer, to impose justice and take decision for another people, the condemned man, when they fail to connect with them, even at a very basic level?

The actual execution is to be carried out by a complex apparatus designed by the former Commandant of the penal colony and maintained by the Officer.

All his talking had no effect on reality, and did nothing to change the Traveller's mind or his own fate. Many people and animals died as a result of these tragedies.

In the penal colony ending

These details, and many others, are those that bring to life the condemned man in the eyes of the reader. While Kafka provides vivid descriptions of the officer, the condemned man and even the soldier, he does not give any visual details to describe the explorer. Thus, he is punished with a quick and brutal death rather than the drawn out and redemptive one that Christ had. However, because the Officer chooses torture out of his own desire to affirm the value of the apparatus, which makes him self-serving, rather than selfless like Christ. Steinberg, Erwin. The central reason for this denunciation is that, for Kierkegaard, belief is willed as a human decision, whereas for Kafka belief is a cognitive exercise. The pieces on which are here conferred, however, are intended to support the philosophical issues that, in a way, overshadow the other aspects. In ancient China there were several dynasties documented in their history. The Officer wants both favor from the Traveller and to continue torturing the condemned prisoners, but upon realizing the hopelessness of his operation, he turns the machine against himself. Religion The Officer's ironic death serves to raise moral questions about religion and the meaning of life. Ronald Gray. The literal power expressed in this circumstance is the terrifyingly swift and merciless punishment being carried out for such a small act. On French Colonial Expansion. The explorer, however, is the embodiment of the post-colonial perspective, who views colonization and the relationship between the colonizer and the colonized within the penal colony with disdain and disapproval.

Columbia, SC: Camden House, The popular critical analysis seems to be that the story is allegorical, where the old Commandant represents either the God of the Old Testament, those that subscribe wholly to the Old Testament but not the New Testament, or something else related directly to the Old Testament.

This strategy is not merely coincidental, and is a conscious master stroke of the genius mind that Kafka was. Another physical attribute of the literal power of the machine is its need for continuous care and attention when it breaks. The focal point of the story corresponds to the visit of the Explorer to the penal colony in order to understand their grotesque way of implementing punishments to the condemned.

Power exists where there is tangible force, justice, and belief. The officer's extreme, crystallized suffering raises him above the universal as an individual. Understanding the importance of such a setting in the context of colonial and post-colonial discourse, it is not difficult to draw parallels with the stereotypical view the colonizers hold of the colonized land.

in the penal colony symbolism

Forster captures this beautiful moment where two of the British characters come across a beautiful bird in a club, but fail to identify it.

It is important to note how the British soldiers took great pride in wearing blaring bright red coats to the battlefield, despite the fact that it provided poor camouflage.

In the penal colony characters

Power exists where there is tangible force, justice, and belief. Any subject. The colonizers, considering themselves to be the superior race, believed they owned the monopoly of culture and civilization, and were in effect doing the colonized nations a favor by enlightening them. His fear, his repulsion, his vindictive smile — all his emotions are duly expressed through the pen of Kafka. The narrator's fixation on the Condemned Man's lack of understanding of his crime and upcoming punishment shows that Kafka favors a system of justice in which someone must understand the law that they have broken to be convicted of a crime, and which allows them the chance to defend themselves. Colonialism, when first introduced in the Americas in , was indeed a process like no other. After making the move of infinite resignation, the tragic hero can act as judge for the universal, for he has nothing to gain in making a decision either way. Ronald Gray. He disapproved of the new Commandant and the new approaches that stripped power away from his machine. The Officer wants both favor from the Traveller and to continue torturing the condemned prisoners, but upon realizing the hopelessness of his operation, he turns the machine against himself. Works Cited Allen, Danielle. He, however, is unaware of this reality, and sees himself as an inherent authority on the systems of the penal colony. Certainly there is a connection between the officer and the teahouse, and the reader may even presume that the officer had spent his free time lounging there, depending on the reader's interpretation of the clientele. The Officer humanizes the machine in this moment and makes it seem more relatable in order to try to win the Traveler over to his way of thinking.

He disapproved of the new Commandant and the new approaches that stripped power away from his machine.

Rated 6/10 based on 85 review
Download
Kafka "In the Penal Colony" Essay